Remux vs hevc reddit 2021. x265 is an encode using the h265 codec.

Remux vs hevc reddit 2021 I’ve considered saving space and sanity and just going for 4K x265 encodes and using the roku again, but can’t find much information on bitrate size vs the remux 4K. Holy cow, I searched remux (thanks, btw, hadn't heard of it) and those were 20 GB to 120 GB. Dune and Event Horizon) has this written in description: "Screenshots can\'t be made for this release because there is no tool to make screenshots out of a mixed dolby vision file. Plus BT. New to the 4KUHD discs, have enjoyed buying them. Remux means the data has been copied (often simply to a new container like mkv) without any changes. Will there be a quality loss here? If I play the same movie on a uhd blu ray, will I notice difference? I think hdr is the key to quality and makes even an encode worth watching over a 1080p remux. REMUX is exact bluray quality. I'm using the, "Tdarr_Plugin_MC93_Migz1FFMPEG Migz-Transcode Using Nvidia GPU & FFMPEG" plugin. If it says "Remux" it's the exact same quality as the files on the physical disc. It is not encoded A remux is definitely encoded. That all changed with UHD Blu-Ray which introduced newer codecs. I think the bluray looks good but without the IMAX shots I don't think it's incredible. One thing to consider would be that 4K is usually "encoded" in 10 bit colour range meaning it can have 4x the colour range of 8 bit, 256 colours vs 1024 colours. If you are are downloading new DV REMUX from FrameStor then their file name won't have HDR but instead DV. There have been so many DV files downloaded that play completely fine with my Bravia X90F. Taking into account that each disc is unlikely to be filled to the brim, and stripping out unneeded audio tracks/bonus features, you're still probably looking at 1. Remux means they shouldn't be further compressed than the disc already is (1:1 quality). 1. 2 channel. H. 4 GB to 2. Hi, i'm looking for an Android TV box or cheap mini PC which will play 4k HDR 10 bit bluray remux over network / nas So far i've tried the NVIDIA sheild tube, 4k FIRE TV 2019, latest google TV stick, Samsung Galaxy S21 ultra using dex, all of which play the movie but drop frames or have occasional stuttering or buffering. 1 afm72) Life (2009) Season 1 S01 (1080p BluRay x265 HEVC 10bit AAC 5. The people who bitch about Judas are the same people who bitch about anything that isn't a bluray remux. Framestor has the file named: DV HEVC REMUX Wildcat has it: DV HDR10+ REMUX OR DV HEVC HYBRID REMUX (couple other movies) Does that mean Wildcat has better fallback to HDR10+ if Dolby vision is not supported, since they also mention hdr10+ in their description. I'm using Tdarr and ffmpeg to attempt to transcode these again staying in h. I usually avoid HDTV copies due to the intermittent blackouts (during commercial breaks) and the ads that pop-up in some shows. I want to extract the dv hevc files from mkv movies to remux them in an mp4 so i can read them in my lgcx. 1 Silence) Life in Cold Blood (2008) Season 1 S01 (576p DVD x265 HEVC 10bit AC3 2. Or 128-bit audio vs 256-bit. The video track alone ended up at 1334 kbps and is HEVC 8-bit. It's a very simple process and doesn't take long (though it's sometimes tedious when the frame counts don't match and you have to figure out how many frames to remove or add, but even that's simple). 4K HEVC is only supported when the file is direct played. We also sometime talk about other canon equipment such as printers. I did comparing tests with Remux, HDB internals, scene encodes and 5,6,7 GB 1080p HEVC encodes and all looks the same Your word means nothing in this discussion. On a pixel level, yes there is loss in detail. If you transcode then why even bother with remux? If you want to use WAN (aka your 30mbit/s connection) then you simply cannot, not without transcoding it. very different experience. Tested in Skyrim, Alyx, Fallout 4 and others games through virtual desktop. I'd like to get a better refinement of these particular qualities, but not sure of the best way to get that. 3) Mux mp4 with the bl_el. Since the audio can’t be direct played, it has to be transcoded. Framestor has the file named: DV HEVC REMUX. 2160p is always HEVC and usually with HDR or even DV. This chip has a hardware HEVC decoder, but it only supports 8-bit SDR color. 3gb while the remux is 27. There is no difference. x265 is an encode using the h265 codec. 2020 is the color space for HDR contents. So if the movie stream of a BD is 40k mbit/s, the Remux of this source should be the same regardless of the remuxer group. Blu-ray themselves are compressed, which is why they use video codec such as AVC, VC1, and HEVC. 264 and VC-1 and only H. 59 (as of 2021-07-01, amazon) and YTS is usually 1. 5 In the newest Plex app on Apple TV, it actually will direct play or direct stream these VC-1 encoded files in an MKV container. I'm looking at the two movies: Top Gun Maverick 2022 and Dune 2021. Nah this isn't true, HEVC is very good at compressing 4k without much quality loss. Blu-Ray 25 or 50 usually. However the stock iPhone camera app doesn't give you any control over the bitrates, you'd need to use something like Filmic Pro to take advantage of that. Is this the correct setting? ffmpeg -i foo. reReddit: Top posts For example when comparing Daredevil The Bluray is 55GB while the WEB. Wildcat has it: DV HDR10+ REMUX OR DV HEVC HYBRID REMUX (couple other movies) Does that mean Wildcat has better fallback to HDR10+ if Dolby vision is not supported, since they also mention hdr10+ in their description. That was with retaining the TrueHD 7. Normally a REMUX would have the word REMUX in the filename. now instead of minutes, substitute audio channels, image compression (per frame). If you transcode then why even bother with remux? The sound of the DUNE 4k bluray is where it really shines in my opinion. If your Dune file was 90Gb then I would be extremely surprised if it was anything other than a 4K remux. On a 55 inch TV sitting from a normal distance on a couch the average person won't notice the difference. 5-2TB of storage required for a the remux. Is this the desired functionality? Should they be transcoded to H265? BluRay is simply the media source. It used to be that you could pretty much garuantee that a blu-ray remux was H. It's particularly noticable in my anime collection, as I'm making a point of getting dual-audio h265 content where possible, and I've got various version labelled with x265, h265 and HEVC. Hello everybody, Yesterday I was browsing the internet and discovered a so called "2160p Hybrid Remux" for the Disney Movie Luca. 264 - pixels, low quality and many changes on the go, hevc - high quality, no visible bitrate changing What you're doing here is called remuxing as . I didn't ask which release type would offer the highest quality overall, since a BluRay REMUX or large BluRay-Rip will obviously be superior in quality to any WEBDL. The remux in MKV format, is just the video/audio/subtitles ripped from the disc and then put into an mkv container. speed for 4K remux so it matches up. Up to you if you prefer original quality or smaller file. 2 GB for a standard-length movie. ts and . A REMUX is a copy of BluRay in different format. 5M subscribers in the Piracy community. 265 encodes can vary a lot depending on the settings chosen. DL in 4k is 94GB Would the 4k version be too compressed (since the source is a streaming site) or is it still superior in quality? Remux is a single file (usually . 2021. 6gb. Remuxes (in MKV format) allow you to preserve multiple audio and subtitle tracks. For content shot digitally without much grain/noise (like a lot of AppleTV+ stuff, or the latest Mission Impossible movie) the difference is small but I can tell if I look closely. Can Tdarr take a 4K Remux and make another copy into 1080 H. If you are stil really, really unsure then read their Mediainfo and looks for HDR format. I have a 65 inch 1080p screen, whats better for me 1080p remux or 2160p blu ray? Usually 2160p blu ray is lower size but whats better for quality I used the following ffmpeg command to remux a 4K HVEC 10bit video file into mp4 so that I could import it into Final Cut Pro X: ffmpeg -i /users/sam/Desktop/video. It’s around 50gb. Everyone should try it out themselves and if they don't notice a difference in quality, just stick to the smaller size. 265/HEVC? I was recommended to look into Tdarr from a post on r/Plex So my goal is to take a 4K remux and make a 1080 copy (maybe 265 or 264). 1 channel audio vs the 7. If any of those movies or shows get a 4k version I remove the 1080p remux and replace it with a small HEVC encode. Hello there. convert the DV in hevc stream to profile 8. HEVC is not a lossless video codec. What makes one remux possibly better is source material for video, audio, or a combination thereof. A remux is a direct extract from the source. A remux is a remux. The source should always be a BD. The higher bit depth alone is enough reason to pick that. There's no such thing as what you see in movies that "enhance" pictures or movies that were already blurry. Problem is that every plugin I have found only transcodes the files if they aren't already HEVC/h. If you have a solid tv and a great sounbar, you could use the REMUX. This is the home of the wedding photographer community on Reddit and the place for wedding photographers, second photographers, assistants, and those aspiring to be wedding photographers. Blu-ray includes extras like languages and behind the scenes. Which one would yall recommend for the best quality? H265/HEVC is a video codec. Debating between 4K Remux vs Encode as I'm in between upgrading some of my encode to remuxes and wondering if I should upgrade my entire collection or just some You have a remux Vs full Blu-ray comparison. In my very anecdotal experience, ~50% of clients can't play HEVC natively. I would go for the REMUX, maybe delete some after, or buy extra storage. anything that isnt a top show and doesnt need good visuals to be watchable will be a lower quality, ranging from 2GB-10GB per movie and 500MB-3GB per episode Strictly speaking, h. Traditionally before dv webdls became common it meant remuxes using video frames or audio tracks from other blurays. My Mi Box S can even do HEVC 4K natively. mkv -c:v copy -tag:v hvc1-c:a copy users/sam/Desktop/video. There’s no reason to get the SDR version unless you’re watching it on hardware that doesn’t support HDR. mkv -vf scale=1920:1080 -c:v libx264 bar. Now, I know these are all the same codec. We ask that you please take a minute to read through the rules and check out the resources provided before creating a post, especially if you are new here. Reddit . 265 with NVENC. This is, when it's a scene release. So a remux simply takes the same v/a streams and moves them from one container to another. Some say theres a huge quality loss converting h264 to h265. You should end up with 3000-6000 kbps for 4K which is way lower than HEVC would go, with equal or better quality in most cases. 7 mb/s the REMUX will have a much higher bits/pixel ratio and all things being equal would look better. HEVC compresses better. 264. The biggest area I see quality problems is movies with lots of dark scenes as you really see the artifacts even with fairly good quality files. Also have to tried comparing the remux with the BD encode? Rather than transcode a whole movie in Handbrake, I'd like to simply remux a film from MKV to MP4. I’ve a remux hevc of a movie in my pc. Oct 6, 2024 · other reason to keep remux is that if the movie/show is amazingly epic in some way like a top 100 IMDb movie I still keep it remux as its a top show/movie imo. x264 and x265 are the encoders (that's the difference between h. Remux is already compressed and encoded from the mezzanine master files. 1 Silence) Interviews Kingdom of Plants (2012) Season 1 S01 (1080p BluRay x265 HEVC 1Obit AAC 5. 1 and discard EL with Dovi Tool this will create a new file BL_EL. mkv but not always) that has been taken from a full source Blu-Ray disc. Next time only download one. 26*). mp4 files are containers for the included video/audio streams. Furthermore, due to HEVC the 2160p picture at 25 Mbit/s is typically very similar to 1080p h264 at let's say 50 Mbit/s. I have a library with a number of REMUX movies that are 60-80GB per file and already encoded in h. Reply reply If you have an 80" TV and unlimited storage space maybe, but remuxs arent perfectly encoded use every bit available at maximum efficiency, theres still a lot of room to shrink stuff while still being mostly imperceptible to most viewers. 265 HEVC. 60 Not interested to do 2 pass Target Bitrate. Bit late to the party but here's your answer: When you go for a private tracker you choose to become their slave in exchange of better content and speed. 2. 4GB with 20RF at VerySlow using CPU. Not to mention the unsightly watermarks usually seen on broadcast TV. 264 or x264. mkv -c copy output. Here's a comparison between 1080p judas HEVC mini encode and a 720p erai h264 encode, if you look at the boat at the left side, the mini encode has literally destroyed the sails and the upper and rear part of the boat, like destroyed to the point they don't even exist in the HEVC mini encode. it is as good of quality as the source contained. Just not *re-*encoded by a third party. First, we binged watch S08-S10 of The Walking Dead Remux 1080p. If it's an encode, then it mostly has x265 or x264 in the filename. Or the 5. Welcome to reddit's home for discussion of the Canon EF, EF-S, EF-M, and RF Mount interchangeable lens DSLR and Mirrorless cameras, and occasionally their point-and-shoot cousins. When you go to make the compression from the original lossless file to an encoded compressed file, you choose your settings based on balancing three things: resulting file size, resulting file quality, and time to do the compression. After digging into this subreddit a little though, it seems people are highly against watching such files since Remux files exist. Source: 2021 year Animation movie, Hint: Robot Bit rate : 28. One is the full disc, usually in the format . Blu-Ray Remux file structure example. hevc & ac3 audio track Hybrid remux mean multiple sources were used, it does not have to mean hdr + dv. Now if bandwidth is not a problem, I usually download both and then make a hybrid file myself with dovi_tool. " I’ve a remux hevc of a movie in my pc. Correct. mp4 extract hevc stream from your mkv with mkvextract. As for the HDR part, both use HDR (as you said) so your theather set-up must be able to handle it. The extra 5% loss in the 1080p might be enough to really notice it. This means that they cut out some of the quality in order to decrease the size. Extract ac3 audio track as well. So for example chapter titles from the dvd, extra commentary from laserdisc etc. A remux is when you rip a Blu-ray/DVD without transcoding the video. Others say there's no difference at all. The counter part to AVC is HEVC which is h. But Sonarr recognises all these, and I'm not really sure why. AVC is a video format. As the quality depends of the release, I will try to take one video as an example BluRay 4KLight DOLBY VISION/HDR10+ x265 10Bit 4 971 kb/s Vs HEVC/x265/h. If I am re-encoding from a TV rip/BD Rip, I usually use HEVC now since most hardware supports it now. Unfortunately I’ve had issues with the pro and miss the roku. mkv Once the encode has finished, I transfer all the color data from the remux to the encode using Nmkoder's color data transfer utility - This includes HDR metadata. 265. Quality-wise, you can get the same quality with either, but HEVC will always be considerably smaller for the same quality (I find especially with animation). With 4K transcoding it's not always about throwing more cores at it, single-core performance also plays a role. Theres been a few times when a superior master was used for a streaming/broadcast copy or the bluray was fucked up due to bad filtering and such leading to a webdl or even hdtv rip being superior. REMUX is the best quality you can get This is usually true, but not always. The smaller Bluray rips use the remux files which are then re-encoded to a smaller size. All questions and photographic experience levels welcome!. 5. Well If you want the best quality available then remux is they way to go but will eat a lot of space. They are usually encoded optimised for streaming already, and I don't want to loose any more quality doing a second re-encoding on them. It is basically another word for h. In the literal big picture, a 50% avg bitrate loss on HEVC encode is usually unnoticeable to most in terms of quality, and most TVs today add some level of post processing to make up that difference, though some are bad at it. 5mb/s and 4K WEB-DL 14. "You log shows that you’ve chosen the TrueHD audio track. hevc. Will I see any difference in quality between the remux and the encode? The 2nd one is in hdr but is 50GB while the 1st one is REMUX and 100GB. It depends on how much you notice. There are two types of remux. For x264 web-rips, I don't bother re-encoding them. So far the quality has been good and the files are just as big as discs. 264 was in very common usage, and the whole point of a remux is that it doesn't touch the source video stream. FGT and EVO (Blu-ray rips) are banned from many trackers because they are trash. Some other shows I enjoy but maybe have a shitload of episodes I will have high quality encodes (for example, I love "House" but I can't really justify 178 remuxed episodes when I can get 95% of the way there with a good encode). With the way HEVC (and now AV-1) are, I find it harder and harder to justify ~3GB+ for audio when my 1080p video tracks after encoding average ~3-8GB depending on how noisy the source is (I exclusively use bluray remux sources, and lightly denoise for particularly bad masters), and 4k HDR compresses even better (somewhere in the vein of 15Mbps Welcome to /r/SkyrimMods! We are Reddit's primary hub for all things modding, from troubleshooting for beginners to creation of mods by experts. 265 (10bit) Dolby Vision 6 212 Kb/s An example is The Day After Tomorrow, the 2160p is 18. An example is The Day After Tomorrow, the 2160p is 18. The CC doesn’t support TrueHD audio. For animated movies, the difference is not noticeable to me. Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now (remux or webdl) while x264 is used for encodes and webrips. My tv supports 4k HDR I have already started downloading the REMUX one but I dont see the HDR tag in the title while the other one does have HDR in the title but no REMUX. 264, because the codecs supported by blu-ray were MPEG-2, H. I've already got 8 drives in my desktop; I'd have to get a server to handle that many :) That stuff will already be HEVC, and take a pretty long time to get done. those guys take forever and pay attention to the easy stuff like banding and artifacts looking for "transparent" encodes. ⚓ Dedicated to the discussion of digital piracy, including ethical problems and legal advancements. Now since it’s not direct playing anymore, the 4K hevc can’t be used and has to be transcoded to h264. 2 Mb/s Encode: Default qcomp=0. The container will usually be an mp4 or mkv file. It depends. It's supposed to be a replacement for the "old", but widely supported and used H264. If Epsilon release has HDR then Framestor will. 26* vs x. I have several examples of large >70GB files that are labeled WebDL's, but seem more like Bluray-2160p instead. HEVC for life, def better than h. mp4 I previously found out that I needed to ensure the file was coded as hvc1 so it would play nice with my Mac. Some recommend only transcoding 4k content or BR remux's to h265. A nice 4K remux movie is often up to 50GByte which if you calculate translates to around a good healthy 50-60Mbit/s which is usually the recommended min. After reading the description it promissed to be a 4K Blu Ray Remux with Dolby Vision Metadata stipped from a WEB-DL and put into the Movie which means it would be best of both world (High Bitrate with Dolby Vision which is exclusive to streaming). New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Also for those remux ones you should have a good monitor/audio equipment. unRaid, Tdarr, Sonarr, Radarr, and Plex user here. Tigoles HEVC vs Remux's I have a 4TB hard drive that I just filled up with a bunch of Tigole's 4k HDR HEVC files since all his bluray rips were so good (and those included commentaries and extras). The video bitrate was ~20-24Mbps. Even a CPU conversion will produce gains that are tiny compared to the amount of time it takes. The biggest difference would be seen between webdl and the remux as the webdl almost certainly doesn't have enough bitrate. 1 audio track, which is hilariously about 2. DL in 4k is 94GB Would the 4k version be too compressed (since the source is a streaming site) or is it still superior in quality? Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now (remux or webdl) while x264 is used for encodes and webrips. Until a REMUX is available. You preserve the "Original Quality" bitrate from the disc. I didn't say that that, either. With the roku only having a 10/100 port, i know the remux bitrate can sometimes go over 100mb and cause issues. The remux will have the best quality because it has the highest bitrate. Blu-Ray 50 file structure example. it might be 1080p, but at 90% JPG while the 720p is 95% JPG. At first, I thought it must be something in my setup. I have a 4K HEVC remux which I would like to scale down to 1080p, but without loosing any quality, yet be AVC rather than HEVC. The HEVC encode also smoothens out the marks on the WEBDL-2160p & Bluray-2160p & Remux-2160p All in Same Profile. I've heard a lot of conflicting information about what file and quality profiles should be downloaded to h265/hevc. If you want to use WAN (aka your 30mbit/s connection) then you simply cannot, not without transcoding it. I just bought my first 4K TV (LG OLED65C9) and I want to start getting some 4K movies. So a BluRay release without the 'remux' tag means that the media has been reencoded and there is loss of quality, while 'remux' means it is lossless. ⚓ A community devoted to in-depth debate on topics concerning digital piracy, ethical problems, and legal advancements. When using GPU to get it done fast, you'll be taking a bit hit on the quality. Most 4K is upscaled (especially when cgi heavy) from the source anyway so its really the hdr that adds the deep color and contrast to make the pq look far superior to the sdr when done right. Download encode and remux and find out if you can tell the difference. I do have a NVidia Shield and just started a Plex share with a large server. 0 i only have hdr10 and hdr no dolby vision in metadata and no dolby vision in tv. Unfotunately, my storage and bandwidth capacity doesn't allow for that. I used to reencode my blue rays now I leave them as remux and my 4k I always try to keep remux same filesize . m2ts, which includes extras and disc navigation. But, lately, the DV files from Rarbg (eg. The probleme is when i try to do this with mkvtoolnix with mkvextractgui v2. The Predator 2018 2160 BluRay Remux DV HDR10+ HEVC Atmos 7 1 Black Widow 2021 2160 BluRay Remux DV HDR10+ HEVC Atmos DTS-HD MA 7 1 Pacific Rim 2013 2160p BluRay Remux DV HDR10+ HEVC TrueHD 7 1 Atmos Mission Impossible Dead Reckoning Part One 2023 Hybrid 2160p UHD BluRay REMUX DV HDR10+ HEVC TrueHD 7 1 Atmos My own Handbrake smashing of Dune (2021) from a MakeMKV rip of the 1080p disk ended up at 5. I wish I had space for that quality but a 16 TB Seagate still costs $531. On paper the 1950x has a PassMark score of ~27K, which in theory should be enough for a 50Mbps 10-bit HEVC transcode, but I had a 2950x for awhile and it would definitely stutter when transcoding and tone mapping high bitrate (70+) 4K HDR content, even though the CPU itself wasn't at Client: Apple TV 4K 2021 model with latest TVOS 15. For example when comparing Daredevil The Bluray is 55GB while the WEB. I just bought a new TV recently and were wondering what is the best choice for quality or perception between HDR10+ and the remux version. Will there be a quality loss here? If I play the same movie on a uhd blu ray, will I notice difference? With 1080p REMUX 25. You only have 2 options: either you pay with your own money (for things like seedboxes, etc. I have a 77” OLED TV, and my experience is…it depends. 265 or x265 just for future Open up The Office on HDB and check the screen comparisons between the remux and the webdl. This probably reflect my ignorance of codecs, but I have a bunch of files that are in HEVC/H264, and TDarr says that they do not need to be transcoded, because the are already HEVC. Reply reply Good encodes (DON, SbR, etc) you will not notice the difference between the remux and the encode. That seems to be the concensus I've found lmao. IMO encodes in the 1-2GB range are fine if you have a good monitor to enjoy them along with good audio setup. I was excited to see that, but I think the implementation must be really really poor. Then came season 11 which hasn’t finished yet so I downloaded the 1080p WEB/WEB-DL files from a tracker. Remux just means that the original h. ) or you need to put your device torrenting 24/7 for them because they have very strict rules and (the worst of all) sharing quotas. I use infuse in my Apple TV 4K to direct play within my local network. 5x the bitrate of the video track I ended up with. 264 is capable of higher quality than HEVC when it comes to retaining fine detail, but you need to use much higher bitrates than you would for HEVC - at least twice as high. The file title should specify the media source and whether it's been re-encoded. Pitch perfect mixing with incredible Atmos and sound design. If you encode a video to both H264 and H265 using settings that produce similar results, the h265 file should be smaller. I'm not saying they're all like that but it's science, lower bitrates means that you'll see the difference from the source. Webdl has a color cast, banding, softer image and encoding artefacts. 0 afm72) The Raspberry Pi model 4 with 4GB of RAM has the Broadcom BCM2711, Quad core Cortex-A72 (ARM v8) 64-bit SoC. A quick Google search gave me the same command from a few different sources: ffmpeg -i input. x26… 20TB storage server/ 4K Remux vs 4K Encode Hi I currently have a server with around 20TB storage and want to upgrade some of my movies to 4K but want the quality to be great, I have a 55 inch 4K samsung tv and usually sit about 5-7 feet away from it. reReddit: Top posts 265 encodes can vary a lot depending on the settings chosen. Galapagos with David Attenborough (2013) SO1 (1080p BluRay x265 HEVC 1Obit AAC 5. Hybrids are the best, but that’s because they are multisourced. This is a discussion based community and it is the place to share business experiences and creative ideas about our work. 265 video and the audio streams have been copied from the disc and not re-encoded to make them even smaller, they are exactly the same as they were on the disc. i know bigger size isnt always better since 2160p is h265 while remux is still h264 Archived post. Remux are all the same quality as they are not encoded Again group doesn't matter for full Blu-ray Blu-ray fish is the full fish image which you would burn to a empty blu ray fish But reagrding to remuxes the different size could be because they use other sources (Source = BD). wtgrl jxf mhc ubnhfuy uhr dzgz egcdwdhd vpiavir wplbfb wnskqec